Roddy McDowall

David Balfour

Sue England

Aileen Fairlie

Dan O'Herlihy

Alan Breck

Roland Winters

Capt. Hoseason

Jeff Corey

Shaun

Houseley Stevenson

Ebenezer

Erskine Sanford

Rankeillor

Alex Frazer

Hugh Fairlie - Innkeeper

Winifriede McDowall

Innkeeper's Wife

Robert J. Anderson

Ransome - Cabin Boy (as Bobby Anderson)

Janet Murdoch

Janet Clouston

Olaf Hytten

The Red Fox

Erville Alderson

Mungo

Jimmie Dodd

Scotsman Sailor (uncredited)

Mary Gordon

Scottish Woman (uncredited)

William Beaudine