Gavin Bellour

Buddy

Elisabeth Moss

Susan

Lee Garlington

Susan's Mom

Matisyahu

Chassid

Annabelle Gurwitch

Rita

Tovah Feldshuh

Buddy's Mom

Tim Guinee

Pete

Dick Latessa

Grandpa

Catherine A. Callahan

Fiona

Geoffrey Wigdor

Raging Randy

Toni Romano

Diner Waitress

Maureen Torsney-Weir

Bar Owner

Michael Elian

Handimart Cashier

Stink Fisher

Biker

Richard Alliger

Bartender (uncredited)

Marc Erlbaum