Marco Carlson

Azrael Thran/Spartacus/Rick/Paul/Jay/Mr. Bittle

Jenna Risk

Lucille Gein

Michael Baker

Michael

Erin Hoodlebrink

Tomboy

Betty Stolar

Lily the Waitress (Red Hair)

Hannah Thomas

Lucy the Waitress

James Retherford

Cult Guard

Denise Schnieders

Cult Waitress

Liv Hoffman

Marie

Mr. Jumpy The Frog

The Frog

Tatum Greenway

Grieving Woman

Michael Ferguson

The most loyal Cult Member

Noah Amsterdam

Flaky Cult Member

Monica Wolfkill

Amy's Mother

Kyle Bavis

Cult Member 2

Marco Carlson