Tori Kamal

Alan Carpenter

Jamie Zin

Satan / Pete / Landlord

Matthew J. Lindblom

Beelzebub Scratch

Jillian Elaine

Candice

Tyler W. Moore

Gary / Additional Voices

Jemma Bayley

Bonnie

Monica Honey

God

David J. Cantu

God / Additional Voices

Melissa White

Elizabeth Lanchester

Elijah Muldrow

Jesus

Ace Dionne

Carla

Carl G. Brooks

Richard

David Wayne Young

Nick

Caitlyn Cody

Lisa

Molly Strickler

Additional Voices

Tyler W. Moore