Andy Griffith

Melchior (voice)

Mike Krause

Balthasar (voice)

Rod Goldfarb

Caspar / Scribe (voice)

Steve Twitchell

Gabriel / Herod (voice)

Catherine Gilbert

Mary (voice)

Ernie Gilbert

Joseph / Tall Shepherd (voice)

Maddie Taylor

Short Shepherd / Caesar / Tax Man / Townsperson (voice)

Ben Chambers

Inn Keeper / Guard (voice)

Jonna Wiseman

Shoppers / Granny (voice)

Yarrow Cheney

Carrie Cheney