Amanda Seyfried

Ann Lee

Lewis Pullman

William Lee

Thomasin McKenzie

Mary Partington / Narrator

Matthew Beard

James Whittaker

Christopher Abbott

Abraham Standerin

David Cale

John Hocknell

Stacy Martin

Jane Wardly

Scott Handy

James Wardley

Jeremy Wheeler

John Townley

Tim Blake Nelson

Pastor Reuben Wight

Daniel Blumberg

Deacon Talmadge Bishop

Jamie Bogyo

Viola Prettejohn

Natalie Shinnick

Shannon Woodward

Mona Fastvold