Ellen Burstyn

Hagar

Christine Horne

Young Hagar

Cole Hauser

Young Bram

Kevin Zegers

John

Elliot Page

Arlene

Dylan Baker

Marvin

Wings Hauser

Older Bram

Jordan Todosey

Child Lottie

Landon Norris

Young John

Sheila McCarthy

Doris

Devon Bostick

Teen Marvin

Aaron Ashmore

Matt

Ted Atherton

Reverend Troy

Samantha Weinstein

Child Hagar

Kari Skogland