Jack Lemmon

Harry Berlin

Peter Falk

Milt Manville

Elaine May

Ellen Manville

Nina Wayne

Linda

Eddie Mayehoff

D.A. Goodhart

Paul Hartman

Doyle

Severn Darden

Vandergist

Alan DeWitt

Dalrymple

Martin Abrahams

Coney Island Attendant (uncredited)

Don Ames

Restaurant Patron (uncredited)

James J. Casino

Bar Patron (uncredited)

Noble 'Kid' Chissell

Bar Patron (uncredited)

Terrayne Crawford

Woman in the Car (uncredited)

Daniel Elam

Bar Patron (uncredited)

Duke Fishman

Bar Patron (uncredited)

Clive Donner