Charles Collins

Jonathan Pride

Frank Morgan

Mayor Don Emilio Perena

Steffi Duna

Serafina Perena

Luis Alberni

Pamfilo (the Jailer)

Victor Varconi

Don Balthazar (Monterey Captain of the Guards)

Rita Hayworth

Specialty Dancer (uncredited)

Jack La Rue

Lt. Chago (Baltazar's Aide)

Alma Real

Blanca (Serafina's Maid)

William V. Mong

Tecolote (Old Indian)

Mitchell Lewis

Pirate Chief

Julian Rivero

Shepherd

John Eberts

Mozo

Eduardo Cansino Jr.

Specialty Dancer (uncredited)

Nora Cecil

Landlady (uncredited)

Jim Farley

Sailor (uncredited)

Lloyd Corrigan