Burt Reynolds

Narrator (voice)

Bill Fagerbakke

Frosty the Snowman (voice)

Larry Miller

Principal Pankley (voice)

Grey DeLisle

Miss Sharpey / Simon Sklarow / Sullivan Sklarow (voice)

Jeannie Elias

Charlie Tinkerton / Librarian (voice)

Evan Gore

Paperboy (voice)

David Jeremiah

Mr. Simple / Townsperson #1 / Mr. Sklarow (voice)

Tom Kenny

Mr. Tinkerton (voice)

Tress MacNeille

Mrs. Simple / Girl #1 (voice)

Candi Milo

Mrs. Tinkerton / Girl #2 (voice)

Kath Soucie

Tommy Tinkerton / Old Sara Simple (voice)

Tara Strong

Sara Simple / Sonny Sklarow (voice)

Vernee Watson-Johnson

Kenn Michael

Walter Wader (voice)

Greg Sullivan