Allison Williams

Peter Pan

Christopher Walken

Captain Hook

Christian Borle

George Darling / Smee

Kelli O'Hara

Mrs. Darling

Taylor Louderman

Wendy Darling

Minnie Driver

Adult Wendy Darling / Narrator

Jake Lucas

John Darling

John Allyn

Michael Darling

Alanna Saunders

Tiger Lily

Caitlin Houlahan

Jane Darling

Jason Gotay

Tootles

Alan H. Green

Cookson

Jacob Guzman

Twin 1

David Guzman

Twin 2

F. Michael Haynie

Slightly

Glenn Weiss

Rob Ashford