Aaron Tveit

Charlie Carroll

Kal Penn

Brice

Abby Elliott

Angela

Annaleigh Ashford

Anne

Kelen Coleman

Lorelei

Haviland Morris

Angela's Mom

Chris Elliott

Angela's Dad

Lauren Miller Rogen

Kathy

Jessica Rothe

Mary

Lewis Black

Charlie's Therapist

Shane McRae

Vince (as Shane Mcrae)

Julia Eringer

Workaholic Hottie

Misty Gonzalez

Background

Scott Hedley

Presidential Debate Attendee

Emily Althaus

Date #3

Benjamin Cox