James Murray

Judas

Jeremy Guskin

Jesus

Ronney Ascher

Manuel Hossenfeffer Rodriguez

Marti Cooney

Mrs. Baker / Hoagie Woman

Laurence Frommer

Mr. Baker

Elizabeth Wood

Mary / Disgusted Angel

David Skigen

Joseph

Sal Vulcano

Lawn Mower Boy / Extra

Matthew Glass

Larry

Hank Poje

James Peterson / God / Smitty

Jonah Zeiger

Vinny (as Jonah Zieger)

Kelley Rae O'Donnell

Play Angel

David Hubbell

Herbie Falafen

James P. Murray

George

Lino Alvarez

Dr. Puglia / Yelling Angel

James Murray