John P. McGinty

Aaron

Preston Sadleir

Ben

Maleni Chaitoo

Ananya

Sydney Morton

Allie

Joshua Castille

Michael

Garrett Zuercher

Steven

Craig Fogel

Jeff

Melissa Golliday

Sapphire

Tony Sheldon

Ben's Father

Jennifer Smith

Ben's Mother

Benjamin Mapp

Dominic

Matthew Bauman

Realtor

Scott Bixby

Grindr Guy

Peregrine Heard

Waitress

Marti Gould Cummings

Drag Queen

Andrew Keenan-Bolger