Andy Richter

Himself

Lauren Lapkus

Andy's Wife

Eddie Pepitone

Santa Claus

Jon Daly

Sappity Tappity

Mike Cassady

Andy's Uncle

Allan McLeod

Talking Gift

Seth Morris

Little Bobby Ducca

Matt Besser

Bjork

Betsy Sodaro

Andy's Mom

Eric Hoffman

Red Sandwich

Diona Reasonover

Andy's Sister

Michael Blaiklock

Andy's Son

Ego Nwodim

Michelle Obama

Liz Plonka