Steve Oedekerk

The Godthumb / Johnny Paesano / Italian Man (voice)

Megan Cavanagh

Bea / Conceited / Old Italian Woman

Cam Clarke

Adopted Lawyer Son / Mr. Henderson

Mark DeCarlo

Thummy / Don Bazzarzini / Wartz

Paul Greenberg

Afraido / Badgerburger Waiter / Elevator Thumb

Rob Paulsen

Mickey / Toll Booth Operator

Eric Trueheart

Doctor

Jim Jackman

Lucky Brassiere / Joey Carbone / Thumb in Stall

David Bourla