Chase Bolnick

Chad

Matthew Woodward

Zack

Jack Caron

Eddie

Brett Glassberg

The Dentist (as B. C. Glassberg)

Edward X. Young

The Doctor

Ben Sinek

Kenny

Sam Kasmin

Nathan

Lilah Grayce

Zack and Eddie's sister

Jay Stoddart

Tooth Fairy

Jay Stoddart

The Tooth Fairy

Pete Jacelone