Mary Martin

Peter Pan

Cyril Ritchard

Mr. Darling / Captain Hook

Lynn Fontanne

Narrator

Maureen Bailey

Wendy / Jane

Margalo Gillmore

Mrs. Darling

Sondra Lee

Tiger Lily

Joe E. Marks

Smee

Norman Shelly

Nana / Crocodile

Joey Trent

John

Kent Fletcher

Michael

Jacqueline Mayro

Liza

Edmund Gaynes

Slightly

Bill Snowden

Curly

Carson Woods

Nibs

Benedict Herrman

First Twin

Vincent J. Donehue