Joey McIntyre

Tony

Mila Kunis

Tina

Krista Allen

Maddy

Priscilla Lopez

Josephina Vitale

Adrian Grenier

Michael

John Fiore

Mr. Nunzio

Dean Edwards

Father Mark

Jon Bernthal

Dominic Fabrizzi

Richard Portnow

Vinnie Black

Sebastian Stan

Johnny Nunzio

Clement Fowler

Uncle Louie

Matthew Saldivar

Barry

Richard Robichaux

Joey

Mary Testa

Sister Clare

Tony Travis

Zeppo the Bartender

Roger Paradiso