Paul Mescal

Franklin Shepard

Ben Platt

Charley Kringas

Beanie Feldstein

Mary Flynn

Mallory Bechtel

Beth Spencer

Hannah Cruz

Gussie Carnegie

Boo Arnold

Mr. Spencer

Leah Loftin

Mrs. Spencer

Lin-Manuel Miranda

Werner Richmond

Minister

Ray L. Perez

Luncheonette Patron

Kate Heron

Auditionee #1

Tiana Stuart

Auditionee #2

Zora Ambrose Ellis

Mary's Work Friend

Jon Reneé

Pianist

Tristan Tierney

Tyler

Richard Linklater