Jennifer Jason Leigh

Carol

Brenda Vaccaro

Betty

Jack Hallett

Lawyer

Nicholas Love

Tom

James Rebhorn

Richard

Tico Wells

Henry

Sam Schacht

Uncle Fletcher

Nina Lora

Carol as a Child

Steve Buscemi

Eddy

Frank Stallone Jr.

Ledray

Denise Dumont

Mariana

Peter Coyote

Sharpe/Larry

Jim Geallis

Lt. Sharpe

Ken Moser

Ledray's Sidekick

Nicholas Cimino

Boy with Kittens

Matthew Chapman