Matthew Settle

Matthew

Tom Everett Scott

Garrett

Gretchen Mol

Liz

Samantha Mathis

Corey

Josh Hutchinson

Sammy

Michelle Stafford

Suzanne

Hilda van der Meulen

Ethel

Cee Cee Michaela

Cee Cee

Joel Polis

William

Chris Jagger

Rolf

Brent Roam

Bartender

Corie Vickers

Theatre Goer

Gina-Raye Carter

Patron (uncredited)

Russell DeGrazier