Piper Collins

Katelin

Peyton J. Evans

Young Susan

Hannah Fierman

Jessica

Zach Galligan

Step Dad

Courtney Hogan

Susan

Jonathan Horne

Jeremy

Courtney Lakin

Abby

Geoff McKnight

Doll Maker

Mason Wells

Jason

LA Winters

Mom

Drew Youngblood

Daniel (segment "Blood for Gold")

Timothy J. Richardson

Brian (segment "Blood for Gold")

Lilliam Gray

Young Jess (segment "Blood for Gold")

Matt Green

Leprechaun (segment "Blood for Gold") (voice)

Nancy Knight

Aunt Sally (segment "Be Careful What You Wish For")

Matt Green