Jeremy Rishe

Marty Kidner

Logan Taylor

Young Marty

Ray Reynolds

Mick

Doug Farrell

The Candyman

Dale E. Turner

Carl

Brian Dale Brown

Jonah

Julius Callahan

Kierst

Mark Beltzman

Sweet Tooth

Maxx Maulion

Gary

Marc Geller

Marshmallow Man

Alex Louis

Childhood Friend

Frankie Petrosino

Little Boy

Nico Petrosino

Young Marty's friend / Kit Kat Kid

Jesse VanDerveer

Ding Dong Kid

Caitlyn Stellwagen

Childhood Friend

Jeffrey Beals

Matthew Beals