Mira Sorvino

Elaine

Joe Pantoliano

Oswald

Ryan Simpkins

Lizzy Muldoun

Michael Urie

James

Maxwell Beer

Jeremy Fink

Steve Grodewald

Tattooed guy

Ryan Glassman

Rick

Christopher King

Garlic Man

Amelia Bullock

Girl Scout

Evan Trevor Thompson

Clay

Marian Seldes

Mabel Billingsly

Heather Braverman

Samantha

Roscoe Orman

Dr. Grady

Betsy Brandt

Madame Zaleski

Seth Kanor

Jeremy's Dad (voice)

Tamar Halpern