Edmond O'Brien

Timothy MacDonald

Michael Pataki

Rev. Paul Jessie Bundy

Marc Lawrence

The Undertaker

Brooke Mills

Grace MacDonald

Paul Prokop

Dr. Patrick Bundy

Arthur Franz

John

Donna Anderson

Shirley

Nadyne Turney

Orphanage Director

Vicki Schreck

Grace as a Child

William Guhl

Sheriff Mike Pender

Pearl Shear

Mrs. Jordan, Shirley's Landlady

Elizabeth Ross

Hospital Receptionist

Mary Carver

Policewoman

Jay Scott

Deputy Sheriff

Tony Vorno

Bum at Landfill (uncredited)

John Hayes