Nick Offerman

Sal

Keith Poulson

Max

Jess Weixler

Lyla

Stephanie Hunt

Clarissa

Kevin Corrigan

Memorial Man

Megan Mullally

Therapist

Kate Lyn Sheil

Ex-wife

Tabyana Ali

Girl at the Birthday Party (as Tabyana Ford)

Marshall Bell

Lyla's Father

Jonathan Togo

Adult Lyle

Anna Margaret Hollyman

Paula

Alex Ross Perry

Pizza Customer #1

Andrew Bujalski

Ambulance Screen Doctor

Bob Byington