Greta Gerwig

Sally Javits

Drew Tarver

Todd

Nicholas D'Agosto

Frank

Tiya Sircar

Juliet

Andrew Santino

Danny Javits

Meg Ryan

Future Sally Javits

Anders Holm

Gavin

Ryan Lee

Justin

Andra Petru

Bar Patron

Johnny Martini

Bar Patron

Carter Bays

Craig Thomas

Emily Spivey